Feeds:
Posts
Comments

Posts Tagged ‘Pat’s Fantasy Hotlist’

This was mentioned recently by Patrick St Denis on his well known blog, Pat’s Fantasy Hotlist. He recommended it, so when I saw a secondhand copy here in Seoul in What the Book?, I bought it. I already knew that Pat, for some reason, likes Dan Brown – and that should have been enough to prevent me wasting my money.

I try to finish any book I start, but sometimes a novel is just too awful. William Horwood’s Duncton Wood was the last one; others include The Crystal Shard by R A Salvatore and the first of Robin Hobb’s Liveship books.

Deryni Rising is actually quite an old fantasy novel – the first edition dates from 1970, which puts it between the growth of popularity of The Lord of the Rings in the sixties and the blooming of contemporary fantasy in the late seventies that wa spearheaded by Terry Brooks’s Shannara series and Stephen R Donaldson’s Thomas Covenant books. This age is perhaps a mitigating factor in the novel’s awfulness. Or perhaps not. TLotR is not really noted for the high literary standard of its writing, either.

Deryni Rising reads to me like a parody of bad fantasy. Here’s an excerpt from the opening paragraphs:

Brion Haldane, King of Gwynedd, Prince of Meara, Lord of the Purple March … was not a big man, though regal bearing and a catlike grace had convinced many a would-be adversary that he was. But his enemies rarely had time to notice this technicality.

… When he spoke, whether with the crackle of authority or the lower tones of persuasion, men listened and obeyed.

This king then gets murdered, but not without giving his heir – conveniently left alive by the bad guys (they have ‘plans’ for him) – a warning of the danger. (This is what’s called an ‘inciting incident’ in literary terminology; they’re usually a bit more subtle than this.)

The novel was shaping up to be pretty basic, cliché, utterly non-challenging stuff; young adult literature in the worst sense. It reminded me of David Eddings’s Pawn of Prophecy, another lame fantasy work I read back in the days when I had more time to read bad novels.

Oh, well; you live and learn.

Advertisements

Read Full Post »

Skimming Pat’s Fantasy Hotlist today, I found some information on R Scott Bakker’s next book, The White-Luck Warrior, which I eagerly await. Said information was in a post on the author’s own WordPress blog, Three Pound Brain (beloved of zombies everywhere). His post concludes with a list of principles he regards as self-evident, and which resonate strongly with my own opinions. Bakker’s ‘No-Dogma Dogma‘ is:

1) Not all claims are equal.

2) The world is ambiguous because it is supercomplex.

3) Humans are cognitive egoists. We are hardwired to unconsciously game ambiguities to our own advantage – to make scripture out of habit and self-interest.

4) Humans are theoretical morons. We are hardwired for groundless belief in invisible things.

5) The feeling of certainty is a bloody pathological liar.

6) Science is a social cognitive prosthetic, an institution that, when functioning properly, lets us see past our manifold cognitive shortcomings, and produce theoretical knowledge.

7) Contemporary culture, by and large, is bent on concealing the fact of 2, 3, 4, and 5.

Read Full Post »